| |
The Evil Sexist Anime Tyranny of Doom
and Other Nasty Stuff!
I understand that most girls in life are constantly thinking about
how they look all the time, and trying their hardest to look their
best when they have to, and many of us guys either ignore it or
take advantage of it, but we really do appreciate it. I think
men need to give women more credit, it isn't easy for them to
be under that kind of pressure all the time, and they are really
doing it for us, so the least we can do is be thankful. I say
this, because anime and video game characters obviously never
have to do this, they are drawn well from birth, and girls in
real life have a hard enough competing with airbrushed magazine
models as it is. So I hope that any female bipeds reading this
will forgive me for admiring fantasy based female caricatures
as extensions of my art and tolerate anything that they may find
sexist. I like to keep my character's breasts small and humble,
but I'm going on a tangent now, so without further delay, I'd
like to talk about the perpetually infamous argument of sexism
in anime.
The specific definition of "sexism" is
very short and general in the actual dictionary, but words are
a tool of humans, and no tool is ever used exactly the same way
by everyone. The literal definition is basically, "Discrimination
on the grounds of sexuality or gender".
The key point of "sexism" is the word
discrimination. Discrimination is an all or nothing word, it can
either mean any a generally notable difference between things
or a specific flat out prejudice. So is anime sexist? Hell yeah,
but before you start rereading this to find points to emphasize
in your hate mail like I know you are going to, listen up and
read on unless you have the attention span of a jellyfish.
There are two main trains of thought in classifying
sexism in anime. A lot of people like to argue about it at length,
but I'll give you the short and narrow on it. One side believes
that women should act powerful, strong willed, self dependent,
ambitious and every bit as tough as their male counterparts to
dispel the sexist stereotype shell. In this respect, they believe
that anime is sexually empowering towards women. The other side
believes that women should be valued and appreciated for their
original roles as gentle, nurturing, soft, patient and temperamental
individuals who are always there for friends and family. These
people believe that portraying anime women in their respected
roles instead of giving them exaggerated persona is more authentic
and unforced, and thus, less sexist. These are the two commonly
debated ideas used to support anime's position on sexism seen
in many anime forums, they often go on for eternity, but miss
the the point like a giant slingshot trying to hit a fly with
an exploding watermelon.
There are a lot of stupid little people out there
who can't separate definition from connotation.* A word is not evil
by nature, it is simply a tool of language, however, when it is
used in context enough times, it begins to take on a flavor. A lot
of sensitive otaku take it the wrong way when people evaluate their
precious anime and tell them it's sexist. Same reason why otaku
get pissed off when you refer to their passion as watching "cartoons".
By literal definition, anime, cartoons and animation are all the
same thing, but the connotation associated with each one is radically
different, and only realistically is it in North America that these
connotations between the three clearly exist.Yeah, yeah, you got
your technical and cultural crap, but I'm not going back into that
Hellhole again unless you want an extra five paragraphs tagged onto
this document.
The reason why otaku should not be offended when anime
is labeled as sexist is simple, just about everything on our planet
can be classified as sexist by the most standard definition of the
word, which is not sexually offensive, or sexually abusive, sexually
stereotypical or sexually ignorant, but simply sexually defined,
meaning that it portrays the generally unavoidable fact that there
is a difference between social roles associated with genders. Sure,
when you think of sexism, the first thing that comes to your mind
are women's right protests, angry feminists, sexual harassment in
the work place and having people treat you unfairly because of your
gender. These are ideas that pop into your head when you first think
of the word, because historically, they were the most directly associated
with "sexism", which in turn, became a negative buzz word
of sorts. By definition however, the accusation of sexism can be
much softer and more natural than you might think, although a lot
of people throw it around without knowing what it fully means as
well. Of course, when otaku hear the whole accusations of sexism
in their favorite form of entertainment, they resort back to their
"Anime is not tentacle rape" argument that they had to
use to defend themselves against mass ignorance for the longest
time. Let's face it, the lot of us know that hentai has a very small
share of the actual anime market, but it is a very loud and novel
share as far as North American is concerned, and along with giant
robots, sweat drops and speed lines, it's right up there in the
top five cliches of doom that normal people associate with anime.
People bringing up that petite little portion of hentai to symbolize
the entire anime world has happened to such a repetitively nasty
degree that many otaku developed a bit of an automated response
to it when brought up, which is something along the lines of "Anime
is not sexist, now watch more or shut up". Yeah, of course
the obligatory exception to every rule follows like a goldfish turds
as it always does, but you get my point. These questions and reactions
are to be expected of both parties, so there really isn't anyone
to blame and not much to do about it, except to try to be polite,
tolerant and indiscriminate, however, it is never a good thing to
be too indiscriminate.
On a hypothetical level, could you imagine what the
world would be like if different genders were not acknowledged?
It'd be that whole perfect world paradox crap all over again and
I'd feel sorry for pregnant women (No ice chips... that would be
sad**). Everything would be equal and there would not be specific
products, services or privileges given to either gender to better
suit them. This is not to mention an extremely inefficient social
system. It's like you have a plant and a rock, and you water both
of them just because you don't want to discriminate. The fact is,
the world is based on descrimination in all it's forms. It is frequently
horrible, and rarely fair, but the world is based upon difference.
Ultimately, the best we can do is embrace difference and work synergistically.
Still, the fact remains that sexism exists in anime, but then again,
last time I checked, it existed everywhere else too. It's not exactly
easy to find a place where men and women can't tell each other apart.
Between the sexual caricatures, the panty shots, the
fan service, the power trip fantasies and the tentacle rape, there
is no way you can tell me that anime does not play off of the female
gender in a way that can be done only with males, that by definition
is "sexist". Now, is anime sexually offensive? That is
the real question.
Now, here's the answer:
Yes - because even a vegetable can be sexually offensive
to someone.***
* Some dictionaries have the second definition of
sexism with the abusive, demeaning, generally nasty connotation
built in, but since the first definition is the vague one about
discrimination as a whole, the points still apply that it can be
an all or nothing term, along with prejudice in general. In many
cases, just about any anime, even Hello Kitty can be interpreted
as sexist by the most generalized standards of the word, however,
very few anime take on a full blown, one sided, completely demeaning,
utterly abusive and obscene prejudice towards one of the sexes that
would piss off any of the gender being portrayed watching it. Remember,
at least half of the things classified as sexism are there because
one gender is attracted to the other and has preset expectations
of what the other would idealistically be. It is one part society
and one part individuality, these things will always change with
time, for better or worst.
** Hahha, sorry. When I wrote that, I had to put a
plug somewhere for my Xynthica series that I am working on. Xyni's
mother, who's name is Gity, loves to eat ice chips, she intentially
puts herself in the hospital just so that she can eat them and pick
up a bag or two. Just thought I'd mention that because it seems
pretty funny.
It is very small and very new, but I hope it grows
with time and plumps when you cook it. Come see Xyni's hair ornament
of the month too!
***Anime and manga are sexually empowering at least
as often as demeaning. Many female artists like Rumiko Takahashi,
CLAMP and Koge Donbo do popular, complex and controversial female
characters, often with big glaring flaws that make them interesting.
That is to say that they don't spare their characters from demeaning
activity and behavior that portrays women in a sexist light, at
least the ones that have gone through puberty. CLAMP in particular
seems to be all over the map in exploiting feminine sexuality in
their more mature works like Miyuki-Chan in Wonderland or Chobits,
and they are only the tip of the iceberg. Shoujo has become popular
in North America, but Josei Manga, or Women's Comics which portrays
more realistic and complex characterization with older characters
still has yet to catch on in North America, although a lot of people
like to call it "Hentai with feelings" as a sort' of generalized
running joke. I believe Moyoko Anno's manga "Happy Mania"
deserves special attention for helping to pave the way there, I
highly recommend it for some really interesting characterization
and something very different from typical manga found in North America.
These days, it is quite rare to actually see a one-dimensional
female character in anime (Sorry, I would say 2D, but that would
be redundant). Even in hentai they seem to actually have a very
human nature, granted, they are eventually gonna' end up being something
along the lines of tentacle bait, but you get my point. For the
most part though, anime and manga aren't noticeably any more sexist
or sexually offensive than any other form of story telling entertainment.
I would not go as far to say that they are any less though, but
you can't deny that there are more famous female anime/manga/video
game characters with a solid fanbase than every comic, cartoon,
book, television show and movie of North American origin combined.
That's a bold statement to say, and I doubt if it's really true,
but hey, it's what it looks like from where I sit. Of course, I'm
kind of cheating here, in North America, nobody really cares about
the character featured in the work, we tend to focus on the celebrity
who draws, writes or plays as the character, but the statement still
holds true to me until I learn different
|
|